Peer Review Lit
Process Physics, Atomization and Film Formation Research: 59 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2001-2026)
August 20, 2026
How droplets become films: the process physics behind every ultrasonic spray application
For the atomization physics behind every study here, capillary waves, cavitation and why viscous liquids resist, see How Ultrasonic Spray Nozzles Work. Papers marked Open access, no paywall can be read free of charge on the publisher's site; a Free copy link goes to the authors' own version in a university or government repository.
| Yr | Publication | Material | What the nozzle did | Freq. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Lonakar et al. Modeling thin film formation by Ultrasonic Spray method: A case of PEDOT:PSS thin films. Organic Electronics 13, 2575-2581. | PEDOT:PSS aqueous ink | Model links droplet arrival/coverage time to evaporation time and predicts smooth versus rough film formation. | 120 kHz |
| 2013 | Bose et al. Process Optimization of Ultrasonic Spray Coating of Polymer Films. Langmuir 29, 6911-6919. | Polymer solutions/films on planar substrates | Design-of-experiments study of nozzle height, substrate temperature, spray speed, solution properties and film quality. | Not reported |
| 2020 | Gao et al. Design and experiment of low-frequency ultrasonic nozzle integrating air-assistant system and acoustic levitation mechanism. International Journal of Agricultural and Biological Engineering 13(6). Open access, no paywall. | Water/test liquids | Nozzle-design study coupling ultrasonic atomization with air assistance; evaluates atomization behavior. | 60 kHz |
Organic electronics, displays and photovoltaics
Ultrasonic nozzles deposit PEDOT:PSS, organic-semiconductor inks, light-emitting polymers, perovskite precursors and VO2 nanoinks as thin multi-pass coatings, from tens of nanometers to micrometers, with thickness, loading and morphology set independently. Fine droplets, low spray momentum and programmed raster motion control roughness, coffee-ring formation, crystallization and large-area uniformity, and the process scales to automated XY and roll-to-roll coating. See also the perovskite thin-film page.
| Yr | Publication | Material | What the nozzle did | Freq. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Steirer et al. Ultrasonic spray deposition for production of organic solar cells. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 93, 447-453. | Organic photovoltaic inks; polymer/fullerene device layers | Fifty thin passes (about 11 nm each) of P3HT:PCBM ink at 0.33 mL/min built a 0.55 µm active layer; chlorobenzene ink gave 3.2% cells after annealing, p-xylene ink crystallized. | 120 kHz |
| 2013 | Tait et al. Concurrently pumped ultrasonic spray coating for donor:acceptor and thickness optimization of organic solar cells. Organic Electronics. | Donor and acceptor organic-semiconductor solutions | Two solutions are independently pumped and mixed at/near the ultrasonic nozzle for composition and thickness control. | Not reported |
| 2014 | Ely et al. Handheld and automated ultrasonic spray deposition of conductive PEDOT:PSS films and their application in AC EL devices. Organic Electronics 15, 1062-1070. | PEDOT:PSS; NMP-modified aqueous inks | Compares ultrasonic spray with airbrush deposition for conductive polymer electrodes. | Not reported |
| 2015 | Gilissen et al. Ultrasonic spray coating as deposition technique for the light-emitting layer in polymer LEDs. Organic Electronics 20, 31-35. | Super Yellow light-emitting polymer in organic solvent | Micrometer droplets merge into a complete wet layer before annealing; evaluated in PLEDs. | Not reported |
| 2016 | Liu et al. Ultrasonic spray coating polymer and small molecular organic film for organic light-emitting devices. Scientific Reports 6, 37042. Open access, no paywall. | PEDOT:PSS and small-molecule organic emitting/transport materials | Ultrasonic atomization plus N2 carrier gas forms micron droplets that merge into ultrathin wetting layers. | Not reported |
| 2017 | Han et al. Exploring the ultrasonic nozzle spray-coating technique for the fabrication of solution-processed organic electronics. Organic Electronics 49, 212-217. | PEDOT:PSS organic electrode ink | Ultrasonic spray compared with conventional air spray for organic-electronic electrodes. | Not reported |
| 2017 | Liu et al. Coffee-Ring-Free Ultrasonic Spray Coating Single-Emission Layers for White Organic Light-Emitting Devices and Their Energy-Transfer Mechanism. ACS Applied Energy Materials. | Multicomponent organic emitting-layer solutions | Process conditions suppress coffee-ring morphology while forming single-emission layers. | Not reported |
| 2017 | Chang et al. Controlled Deposition and Performance Optimization of Perovskite Solar Cells Using Ultrasonic Spray-Coating of Photoactive Layers. ChemSusChem 10, 1405-1412. | Lead-halide perovskite precursor inks | One-step ultrasonic spray coating tuned by concentration, precursor ratio, mixed solvent and post-annealing. | Not reported |
| 2018 | Chou et al. Scalable Ultrasonic Spray-Processing Technique for Manufacturing Large-Area Perovskite Solar Cells. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces. | Perovskite photoactive-layer precursor; ITO/PEDOT:PSS stack | Commercial ultrasonic nozzle used for scalable perovskite layer deposition. | 80 kHz |
| 2018 | Bishop et al. High-Efficiency Spray-Coated Perovskite Solar Cells Utilizing Vacuum-Assisted Solution Processing. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 10, 39428-39434. | Metal-halide perovskite precursor inks | Ultrasonic spray casting combined with vacuum-assisted solvent removal to improve coverage/crystallization. | kHz range stated; exact value not reported |
| 2018 | Cheng et al. Realization of Large-Scale Polymer Solar Cells Using Ultrasonic Spray Coating. Solar RRL. | PTB7:PC71BM polymer solar-cell active-layer ink | Modified ultrasonic spray coating applied to larger-area polymer solar cells. | Not reported |
| 2019 | Large-area OLED study Ultrasonic spray coating as an approach for large-area polymer OLEDs: influence of thin-film processing and surface roughness on electrical performance. AIP Advances 9. Open access, no paywall. | TFB hole-transport polymer | Compares spray- and spin-coated films over device-relevant thicknesses; links roughness to injection efficiency. | Not reported |
| 2021 | Youn et al. A study on the change of VO2 thin-film coating behavior according to the deflector flow rate in ultrasonic spray coating. Applied Physics A. | VO2 nanoink on PEN | Deflector gas changes evaporation and droplet fluidity; too much gas causes premature drying and nonuniform film. | Not reported |
Fuel cells, electrolysis and electrochemical devices
Here the nozzle is a precision applicator for catalyst inks and electrolyte precursors. Platinum/carbon-ionomer inks sprayed onto membranes or gas-diffusion layers cut precious-metal loading and improve catalyst distribution. Droplet size, ink rheology and pass count set catalyst-layer porosity and morphology, building a porous layer rather than a dense film. Acoustic agitation at the nozzle limits agglomerates, though ink dispersion chemistry still matters. See also the gas diffusion electrodes application note.
| Yr | Publication | Material | What the nozzle did | Freq. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Millington, Whipple & Pollet A novel method for preparing proton exchange membrane fuel cell electrodes by the ultrasonic-spray technique. Journal of Power Sources 196, 8500-8508. | Pt/C catalyst + Nafion binder inks on GDL/GDE substrates | Ultrasonic spraying used to fabricate low-Pt gas diffusion electrodes and compared with hand painting/commercial electrodes. | 120 kHz |
| 2012 | Huang et al. Ultra-low Pt loading for proton exchange membrane fuel cells by catalyst coating technique with ultrasonic spray coating machine. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 37, 13872-13879. | Pt/C + ionomer catalyst ink on PEM | Catalyst-coated membrane fabrication at ultra-low Pt loading. | 48 kHz |
| 2020 | Alinejad et al. Testing fuel cell catalysts under more realistic reaction conditions: accelerated stress tests in a gas diffusion electrode setup. Journal of Physics: Energy 2, 024003. Open access, no paywall. | Pt-based catalyst ink on gas-diffusion layer | Catalyst ink sprayed with an ultrasonic spray nozzle onto heated GDL for realistic GDE testing. | Not reported |
| 2021 | Li et al. Numerical Investigations on the Ultrasonic Atomization of Catalyst Inks for Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells. Journal of The Electrochemical Society. | PEMFC catalyst inks (particle/ionomer/solvent suspensions) | Models ultrasonic-nozzle droplet formation and links ink properties/operating conditions to atomization. | Not reported |
| 2021 | Ko et al. Thin layer electrolyte impregnation into porous anode-supported fuel cell by ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. | SOFC electrolyte precursor/nanopowder suspensions | Ultrasonic spray/pyrolysis used for thin electrolyte-related infiltration/deposition in porous SOFC structures. | Not reported |
| 2022 | Pan et al. Ordered CoPt oxygen reduction catalyst with high performance and durability. Chem Catalysis 2(12), 3559-3572. Open access, no paywall. | Ordered CoPt catalyst; ionomer-containing catalyst ink | Catalyst deposited onto preheated membrane by a programmed ultrasonic spray nozzle. | Not reported |
| 2025 | Cecchetti et al. Ultrasonic Spray Coating for the manufacturing of a selective layer for flow batteries: From the analysis of ink composition to component scale-up. Journal of Power Sources. Open access, no paywall. | Selective-layer ink deposited on flow-battery membrane | Develops ink-to-component scale-up using ultrasonic spray coating. | Not reported |
Spray pyrolysis, ceramics, oxides and nanoparticle synthesis
In spray pyrolysis and oxide-film work the nozzle turns precursor solutions into repeatable droplets that act as individual reactor volumes, carried through a hot zone to form particles or onto a heated substrate to form semiconductor and ceramic films. Droplet diameter, precursor concentration, residence time and temperature govern particle size, morphology, agglomeration and crystallinity. Acoustic agitation at the nozzle reduces agglomerates in ceramic suspensions, and incremental deposition preserves porosity in products such as zeolite films. A 2022 self-driving-laboratory study used the same route to spray-coat palladium by combustion synthesis at 191–226 °C, with conductivity comparable to sputtered films. The table opens with a 1999 pneumatic-spray baseline (Bisht et al.), included for the transparent-conducting-oxide data a low-E glass process is measured against; it is not an ultrasonic study and is not counted in the 59. See also the spray pyrolysis page.
| Yr | Publication | Material | What the nozzle did | Freq. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1999 | Bisht, Eun, Mehrtens & Aegerter. Comparison of spray pyrolyzed FTO, ATO and ITO coatings for flat and bent glass substrates. Thin Solid Films 351, 109-114. Free copy (author version) | Ethanolic MBTC + HF (FTO), SnCl₄ + SbCl₃ (ATO) and InCl₃ (ITO) precursor solutions on 12 × 12 cm borosilicate glass at 500–550 °C | Pneumatic, not ultrasonic: a conventional hand spray gun (SATA Mini Jet, 0.5 mm nozzle, 1–2 bar compressed air, 13–17 mL/min) in 3 s bursts with 30 s pauses to limit substrate cooling. Baseline resistivity, visible transmission and IR-reflectance data for spray-pyrolyzed TCOs on flat and bent hot glass. Added 2026-09-30; not counted in the 59. | n/a (pneumatic) |
| 2001 | Zhou et al. Preparation of indium tin oxide films and doped tin oxide films by an ultrasonic spray CVD process. Applied Surface Science 172, 245-252. | ITO and doped SnO2 precursor solutions | Ultrasonic spray-CVD used to deposit transparent conductive oxide films. | Not reported |
| 2004 | Song et al. Ultrasonic Spray Pyrolysis for Synthesis of Spherical Zirconia Particles. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 87(10). Open access, no paywall. | Zirconium precursor solution - ZrO2 particles | Ultrasonic spray pyrolysis produces spherical ceramic particles from precursor droplets. | 120 kHz (UMTF nozzle) |
| 2005 | Pingali, Rockstraw & Deng Silver Nanoparticles from Ultrasonic Spray Pyrolysis of Aqueous Silver Nitrate. Aerosol Science and Technology 39, 1010-1014. Open access, no paywall. | Aqueous AgNO3 - Ag nanoparticles | Ultrasonic aerosol generation followed by thermal decomposition/reduction. | ~20–120 kHz range |
| 2008 | Nyutu et al. Ultrasonic Nozzle Spray in Situ Mixing and Microwave-Assisted Preparation of Nanocrystalline Spinel Metal Oxides: Nickel Ferrite and Zinc Aluminate. Journal of Physical Chemistry C. | Ni/Fe precursor solutions - NiFe2O4; Zn/Al precursors - ZnAl2O4 | Ultrasonic nozzle enables fine in-situ precursor mixing before microwave reaction. | 48 or 120 kHz |
| 2010 | Yoon et al. The Route for Synthesis of Agglomeration-Free Barium Strontium Titanate Nanoparticles Using Ultrasonic Spray Nozzle System. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 93, 998-1002. | Ba-Sr-Ti precursor solution - (Ba,Sr)TiO3 nanoparticles | Ultrasonic spray-nozzle route targets agglomeration-free dielectric nanoparticles. | Not reported |
| 2017 | Firat et al. Ultrasonic Spray Pyrolysis Deposited Copper Sulphide Thin Films. Materials / open-access journal article. Open access, no paywall. | Copper/sulfur precursor solution - CuS thin films on glass | Films deposited through an ultrasonic nozzle using air carrier gas. | Not reported |
| 2018 | Lam et al. High-throughput fabrication of zeolite thin films via ultrasonic nozzle spray deposition. Microporous and Mesoporous Materials. | Pure-silica MFI zeolite precursor/particles | Ultrasonic nozzle spray deposition compared with conventional spin-on deposition. | Not reported |
| 2020 | Bi2O3 coating study Thin Coatings of alpha- and beta-Bi2O3 by Ultrasonic Spray Coating. ChemistryOpen. Open access, no paywall. | Bismuth-oxide precursor/particle formulations - alpha/beta Bi2O3 films | Ultrasonic spray coating produces thin bismuth oxide coatings with phase control. | Not reported |
| 2021 | Bose et al. Elaboration of high-transparency ZnO thin films by ultrasonic spray pyrolysis with fast growth rate. Superlattices and Microstructures 156, 106945. Open access, no paywall. | Zinc precursor solution - ZnO thin films | Ultrasonic aerosol delivery improves deposited yield and supports transparent ZnO film growth. | 250 kHz |
| 2022 | MacLeod, Parlane, Rupnow et al. A self-driving laboratory advances the Pareto front for material properties. Nature Communications 13, 995. Open access, no paywall. | Palladium combustion-synthesis precursor ink (Pd nitrate with acetylacetone, glycine or urea fuels in acetonitrile) on heated glass | A self-driving laboratory mapped the conductivity vs. processing-temperature Pareto front by drop casting; three Pareto recipes were then spray-coated at 191–226 °C with an ultrasonic nozzle, giving 50–60 nm films with conductivity up to 2.0 × 10⁶ S/m, comparable to sputtered palladium. Methods name the nozzle as "Microspray, USA". | 120 kHz |
| 2023 | USN-QTR study Ultrasonic Spray Nozzle-Mediated Green Activation for Sustainable Porous Carbon Production. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering. | Water/steam aerosol applied to carbonaceous char | Ultrasonic spray nozzle generates water droplets/steam in a quartz-tube reactor for carbon activation. | Not reported |
| 2024 | Gunes et al. Enhancing p-SnS thin films and fabrication of p-SnS/n-Si heterojunction structures via ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. Applied Physics A. Open access, no paywall. | Tin/sulfur precursor solution - SnS on glass and n-Si | 100 kHz ultrasonic nozzle atomizes precursor at controlled flow for heated-substrate deposition. | 100 kHz |
Medical devices, biomaterials and analytical sample preparation
Ultrasonic spraying is used for conformal, dose-controlled deposition on complex biomedical surfaces — sirolimus/polymer coatings on coronary stents and bioresorbable scaffolds, MALDI matrix deposition, bioactive coatings on magnesium, and barrier layers on biodegradable polymers. The shared advantage is a low-momentum fine spray that builds thin layers by repeated passes, so drug dose is tuned through concentration, flow rate and layer count without changing device geometry.
| Yr | Publication | Material | What the nozzle did | Freq. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 | Chen et al. Study of drug-eluting coating on metal coronary stent. Materials Science and Engineering C 33, 1476-1480. | PLGA polymer + sirolimus on metal coronary stents | Drug-polymer coating prepared by ultrasonic spray coating and evaluated for morphology/release behavior. | Not reported |
| 2019 | Roopmani et al. Development of Dual Drug Eluting Cardiovascular Stent with Ultrasonic Spray Coating. ACS Biomaterials Science & Engineering. | Dual-drug/polymer formulations on cardiovascular stents | Ultrasonic spray-coating parameters optimized for dual-drug stent coating. | Not reported |
| 2022 | Meng et al. Development of an Automatic Ultrasonic Matrix Sprayer for MALDI Mass Spectrometry Imaging. Analytical Chemistry. | MALDI matrix solutions on tissue/sample sections | Piezoelectric ultrasonic nozzle automates fine and uniform matrix deposition. | Not reported |
| 2023 | Fang et al. A multifunctional osteogenic system of ultrasonically spray deposited bone-active coatings on plasma-activated magnesium. Journal of Magnesium and Alloys 11(8), 2719-2739. Open access, no paywall. | Nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) + silk fibroin (SF) on plasma-activated Mg-Zn-Ca alloy | Layer-by-layer ultrasonic spray deposition of nHA/SF bone-active coatings on plasma-activated magnesium alloy. | Not reported |
| 2023 | Cabrini et al. Ultrasonic spray deposition of PEGDE-crosslinked chitosan/graphene oxide coatings for enhancing gas barrier properties of polybutylene succinate films. Progress in Organic Coatings 183, 107760. Open access, no paywall. | Chitosan + PEGDE + graphene oxide on plasma-activated poly(butylene succinate) (PBS) | Ultrasonic spray builds mono-/multi-layer chitosan/GO barrier coatings after plasma activation of PBS. | Not reported |
| 2025 | Jelonek et al. Evaluation of Ultrasonic Spray Method for Application of Sirolimus-Eluting Coating on Bioresorbable Vascular Scaffolds. International Journal of Molecular Sciences 26(15), 7649. Open access, no paywall. | Sirolimus-containing biodegradable polymer coating on vascular scaffold | Evaluates ultrasonic spray coating as a controlled drug-layer application method. | Not reported |
Food, pharmaceutical powders and microencapsulation
The nozzle acts as a droplet generator upstream of spray drying, vacuum drying and spray freeze-drying. The initial droplet population strongly influences dried-particle diameter, porosity, powder morphology, encapsulation efficiency, protein and probiotic stability, and pulmonary aerosol performance. Ultrasonic atomization is especially attractive where narrow droplet distributions and gentle low-temperature processing help preserve sensitive materials. Spray-dried particles are also a case where retained porosity, not a dense product, is the goal, and the initial droplet population sets that microstructure.
Carbon nanomaterials, batteries, composites and functional surfaces
These papers place nanoparticles, graphene and carbon-nanotube dispersions, battery active materials and functional resists onto fibers, textiles, polymer films, additively manufactured parts and non-planar optics. Multi-pass deposition raises loading incrementally while maintaining conformality and limiting runoff. Recurring concerns are suspension stability, surface wetting, porous-substrate penetration and scalable automated coating of three-dimensional surfaces. Acoustic agitation at the atomizing surface reduces agglomerates in graphene and silicon nanoparticle suspensions, but no nozzle rescues an unstable formulation, so dispersion chemistry upstream still decides the outcome.
| Yr | Publication | Material | What the nozzle did | Freq. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Martinez-Garcia et al. High rate and durable, binder free anode based on silicon loaded MoO3 nanoplatelets. Scientific Reports 5, 10530. Open access, no paywall. | Silicon nanoparticle suspension in isopropanol/ethanol on MoO3 structures | 48 kHz ultrasonic nozzle deposits controlled Si nanoparticle loadings by repeated passes. | 48 kHz |
| 2016 | Bastwros & Kim. Ultrasonic spray deposition of SiC nanoparticles for laminate metal composite fabrication. Powder Technology 288, 279-285. Open access, no paywall. | SiC nanoparticles in suspension on composite reinforcement/substrate | Ultrasonic spray deposition used for controlled nanoparticle placement. | Not reported |
| 2017 | Patel et al. Layer-by-layer, ultrasonic spray assembled 2D and 3D chemically crosslinked carbon nanotubes and graphene. Journal of Materials Research. Open access, no paywall. | Carbon nanotubes and graphene dispersions with chemical crosslinking | Automated XYZ ultrasonic spray nozzle forms multilayer 2D/3D carbon assemblies. | Not reported |
| 2017 | Slegers et al. Surface Roughness Reduction of Additive Manufactured Products by Applying a Functional Coating Using Ultrasonic Spray Coating. Coatings 7, 208. Open access, no paywall. | Functional polymer/nanocomposite smoothing coating on additively manufactured surfaces | Ultrasonic spray applies wet coating precisely enough to smooth printed surface topography. | 120 kHz |
| 2020 | Sadanandan et al. Graphene coated fabrics by ultrasonic spray coating for wearable electronics and smart textiles. Journal of Physics: Materials 4, 014004. Open access, no paywall. | Graphene nanoplatelet suspensions on textile fabrics | Ultrasonic spray coating used to produce conductive textile electrodes. | 48 kHz |
| 2021 | Abbas et al. Oxygen Gas and UV Barrier Properties of Nano-ZnO-Coated PET and PHBHHx Materials Fabricated by Ultrasonic Spray-Coating Technique. Nanomaterials 11, 449. Open access, no paywall. | ZnO nanoparticle coating on PET and PHBHHx polymer films | Ultrasonic spray coating applies controlled nano-ZnO functional barrier layers using repeated coating passes. | Not reported |
| 2021 | Supreeti et al. Development and Implementation of a Rotating Nanoimprint Lithography Process for Non-Planar Optics. International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing-Green Technology. Open access, no paywall. | AMONIL MMS4 imprint resist on plano-convex lenses | Ultrasonic spray coating provides multi-layer resist coverage on curved/non-planar surfaces. | Not reported |
| 2022 | Tisdale et al. Microstructural and Sensitivity Changes of Neat, Spray-Dried Energetic Materials Produced with an Ultrasonic Nozzle. ACS Omega. Open access, no paywall. | Energetic-material solutions/suspensions converted to spray-dried particles | Ultrasonic nozzle controls droplet generation and resulting particle microstructure/sensitivity. | Not reported |
| 2025 | Burns et al. Ultrasonic Spray Coating of Carbon Fibers for Composite Cathodes in Structural Batteries. Electrochem 6, 13. Open access, no paywall. | Cathode active-material/binder/conductive ink on carbon fibers | Computer-controlled ultrasonic nozzle coats carbon fibers while retaining mechanical integrity. | Not reported |
| 2025 | Alinejad et al. Ultrasonic Spray Coating of Graphene Oxide for Lithium Metal Battery Separators. ACS educational/chemical engineering journal article. Open access, no paywall. | Graphene oxide in deionized water on polyolefin separator | Ultrasonic spray creates a conformal GO layer intended to improve lithium-metal cell behavior. | Not reported |
MXene and 2D nanomaterial films
MXenes such as Ti₃C₂Tₓ are processed almost exclusively from aqueous colloidal dispersions of micron-scale flakes. That feedstock, low in viscosity and solids, shear-sensitive and expensive, is exactly what ultrasonic atomization handles well: no orifice to clog, low droplet velocity so flakes lie flat rather than splash, a narrow droplet size distribution for uniform film build, and high transfer efficiency for costly inks. The sources below show spray-coated MXene films performing as transparent conductors, EMI shields, antennas, solar-cell electrodes and membrane layers, and include the first industry-scale demonstrations using ultrasonic spray.
This cluster was compiled in September 2026 as a supplement to the 59-study map above and is not counted in it. Each entry gives the deposition method its authors state: only sources that name the atomizer are described as ultrasonic spray, and the rest are listed as spray-coated. All of this work was done by the cited groups on their own equipment. The companion white paper, Ultrasonic Spray Deposition of MXene (Ti₃C₂Tₓ) Thin Films, draws a starting process window from these sources.
| Yr | Publication | Method stated | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | Hantanasirisakul et al. Fabrication of Ti₃C₂Tₓ MXene Transparent Thin Films with Tunable Optoelectronic Properties. Advanced Electronic Materials 2, 1600050. | Spray coating (aqueous and ethanol dispersions) | First scalable spray route to transparent conductive MXene films: homogeneous, pinhole-free films on glass and flexible polyester, with sheet resistance stable to a 5 mm bend radius. |
| 2019 | Cloots et al. Process of ultrasonic spray pyrolysis deposition of one or more electrochromic and/or electrolytic films on a substrate. US Patent 10,254,614 (INISMa and University of Liège). | Ultrasonic spray pyrolysis | Claims a documented process window for an adjacent oxide-film process: 80–120 kHz nozzle, 0.1–2 mL/min, 3–6 cm standoff, 200–450 °C substrate. |
| 2020 | Chen et al. Flexible, Transparent, and Conductive Ti₃C₂Tₓ MXene–Silver Nanowire Films with Smart Acoustic Sensitivity for High-Performance Electromagnetic Interference Shielding. ACS Nano 14, 16643–16653. | Spray coating | An MXene overcoat welds silver-nanowire junctions; shielding effectiveness rises from 21 dB to 34 dB at the same nanowire density, with better mechanical and environmental stability. |
| 2021 | Zhou et al. Flexible hydrophobic 2D Ti₃C₂Tₓ-based transparent conductive film with multifunctional self-cleaning, electromagnetic interference shielding and Joule heating capacities. Composites Science and Technology 201, 108531. | Spraying and spin coating | MXene layer on polycarbonate under a superhydrophobic silica topcoat; stable through 1000+ bend cycles and 100 days outdoors. |
| 2022 | Aydin et al. Scaled Deposition of Ti₃C₂Tₓ MXene on Complex Surfaces: Application Assessment as Rear Electrodes for Silicon Heterojunction Solar Cells. ACS Nano 16, 2419–2428. Open access, no paywall. | Ultrasonic spray (automated coater) | Conformal ~55 nm films (~8000 S/cm) over pyramid-textured silicon; above 20% efficiency on 243 cm² industry-size wafers, with 99% of it retained after 600 days in air. The clearest demonstration of ultrasonic spray on a textured substrate. |
| 2023 | Tong et al. Efficient Pervaporation for Ethanol Dehydration: Ultrasonic Spraying Preparation of Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA)/Ti₃C₂Tₓ Nanosheet Mixed Matrix Membranes. Membranes 13, 430. Open access, no paywall. | Ultrasonic spraying onto a PTFE nanofiber support | Thin (~1.5 µm), homogeneous, defect-free PVA/MXene separation layer, attributed to the gentle low-velocity deposition. |
| 2023 | Guo et al. Rational Design of Ti₃C₂Tₓ MXene Inks for Conductive, Transparent Films. ACS Nano 17, 3737–3749. Open access, no paywall. | Blade coating (compared with spray and spin) | Large-flake (~12 µm) inks and a compact microstructure give a record figure of merit for MXene transparent electrodes: the benchmark sprayed films have to match. |
| 2024 | Gogotsi & Anasori. Antennas comprising MXene films and composites. US Patent 11,862,847 (Drexel University). | Spray coating of aqueous Ti₃C₂ ink | Spray-coated Ti₃C₂ dipole antennas at several thicknesses; a ~5 µm film reached 1.1 dBi peak gain against 1.7 dBi for copper. |
| 2024 | Gogotsi, Hantanasirisakul, Koo et al. Transition metal carbonitride MXene films for EMI shielding. US Patent 12,048,132 (KIST and Drexel University). | Spray coating on glass, annealed at 150–350 °C | Micrometer-thick Ti₃CNTₓ and Ti₃C₂Tₓ sprayed films keep adhesion and conductivity through heat treatment. |
| 2024 | Kim & Byun. Research Trends in Electromagnetic Shielding using MXene-based Composite Materials. Journal of Korean Powder Metallurgy Institute 31, 57–76. Open access, no paywall. | Review; cites ultrasonic spray self-assembly of rGO/MXene/Fe₃O₄ microspheres | Ultrasonic atomization used to form composite microspheres for EMI absorbers: a particle-synthesis use of the nozzle rather than a film. |
| 2025 | Furchner et al. Ti₃C₂Tₓ MXene Thin Films and Intercalated Species Characterized by IR-to-UV Broadband Ellipsometry. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 129, 500–507. Open access, no paywall. | Spray coating of an aqueous dispersion on glass | Thickness heterogeneity and roughness shift the optical constants, and the deposition technique strongly affects electrochemical behavior: the case for uniform droplet delivery. |
| 2026 | Li & Su. The Study on the Capacitive Properties of Tungsten Oxide/Graphene Composites Prepared by Ultrasonic Spray Deposition. ACS Omega 11, 8303–8314. Open access, no paywall. | Ultrasonic spray deposition on FTO | Thickness set by spray passes or feed rate with low solvent use; sol-gel plus ultrasonic spray for 2D-composite electrodes. |
| 2026 | Li & Chen. Ultrasonic Spray Deposition of Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose Polymer Electrolyte Films. ACS Omega 11, 43694–43704. Open access, no paywall. | Ultrasonic spray deposition | Aqueous polymer electrolyte films above 95% transmittance, with flow rate and layer count as the control variables. |
| 2026 | Venkatram et al. (Penn State and UCT Prague). Two-dimensional crystalline hard masks for high-aspect-ratio nanofabrication. Nature Materials 25, 737–746. | Not sprayed: crystalline 2D flakes used as etch masks | Layered crystalline 2D hard masks withstand deep, high-aspect-ratio silicon etching. There is no liquid step, so taking them to full wafers points to growth from vapor, where an ultrasonic nozzle's published role is the precursor feed for CVD and MOCVD (see the Photoresist & Polyimide Coating page). |
Cross-cutting research connections
| Connection | Where it recurs | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Wet-film coalescence vs. dry deposition | Organic electronics, polymer films, VO2, perovskites, surface smoothing | If droplets stay mobile on arrival they level and merge. Too dry and discrete deposits create roughness; too wet and flooding or dewetting occurs. |
| Evaporation-controlled droplet evolution | Perovskites, VO2, spray drying, spray pyrolysis | Carrier gas, standoff, substrate temperature and solvent volatility change droplet diameter and solids concentration during flight. |
| Frequency and liquid properties set droplet size | Atomization studies, food microencapsulation, pulmonary powders, catalyst inks | Higher frequency generally shifts toward smaller droplets; viscosity, surface tension, density and solids loading modify the response. |
| Multi-pass loading control | Fuel cells, silicon nanoparticle anodes, OLED and PV layers, stents | Repeated thin passes decouple total loading from single-pass wetness, permitting precise mass and thickness control. |
| Agglomeration management | Platinum/carbon catalyst ink, graphene, silicon and silicon-carbide nanoparticles, ceramic precursors | Ultrasonic energy at the nozzle helps prevent large agglomerates at the final atomization point, but stable colloid formulation remains necessary. |
| Porosity retention | Catalyst layers, flow-battery selective layers, spray-dried powders | Fine, incremental deposition can preserve or deliberately create porous structures with high accessible surface area. |
| Coffee-ring and lateral solute migration | OLEDs, PEDOT:PSS and other solution-processed films | Capillary flow concentrates solute at droplet edges; process windows suppress this through droplet overlap, substrate temperature and solvent choice. |
| Conformal coating on complex geometry | Stents, carbon fibers, textiles, non-planar optics, porous electrodes | Low-momentum droplets plus programmable motion coat around small or three-dimensional features with less runoff than higher-momentum sprays. |
| High-value material utilization | Platinum catalysts, drug coatings, specialty polymers, perovskite inks | Reduced overspray is most compelling where the coating contains expensive functional material. |
| Scale-up via automation | Solar cells, organic electronics, flow batteries, textiles | Raster motion, programmable passes, multi-nozzle concepts and controlled carrier gas adapt the process from lab coupons to larger components. |
In-depth articles
Longer reads from the MicroSpray library.
Basics of Ultrasonic Atomization
January 1, 2015
Foundational overview of how ultrasonic atomization works and its applications in thin-film coating.
Read the article →Understanding Energy in Motion
Daniel A. Russell · January 1, 2015
Fundamentals of longitudinal and transverse wave motion, acoustic phenomena, and energy propagation through media.
Read the article →Automated Coating Optimization with MicroSpray Nozzles
January 1, 2023
Self-driving laboratory uses Bayesian optimization to autonomously scale up high-performance palladium film deposition via ultrasonic spray combustion.
Read the article →Ultrasonic Spray-CVD: A Versatile Route to Thin-Film Devices
January 1, 2015
Pulsed ultrasonic nozzles in direct-injection CVD for polymer, metal-organic, and ceramic films across MEMS, OLEDs, and SAW sensors.
Read the article →Transparent Electronics, Fully Spray-Fabricated
January 1, 2016
First fully spray-combustion synthesized all-oxide thin-film transistors for flexible, transparent electronics.
Read the article →Ultrasonic Spray of Quantum Dots
June 24, 2014
Precision deposition of quantum dots using ultrasonic nozzles for photovoltaics and displays.
Read the article →Amazing Graphene Ultrasonic Spray Applications
August 3, 2014
How ultrasonic spray technology enables graphene coating for electronics and materials science.
Read the article →Superhydrophobic Graphene Coating
May 15, 2014
Creating superhydrophobic surfaces with ultrasonic graphene deposition techniques.
Read the article →Ultrasonic Atomization for Metal Powder Production
January 1, 2023
High-power 20 kHz and 70 kHz ultrasonic systems engineered for narrowly distributed droplet atomization targeting additive manufacturing.
Read the article →Ultrasonically Spray-Dried Peptide Formulations
January 1, 2025
25 kHz ultrasonic nozzle spray-drying of peptide solutions produces larger, more process-friendly particles than conventional bi-fluid nozzles.
Read the article →Combustion Chemistry of Rocket Fuel Pyrolysis
January 1, 2025
HTPB/AP pyrolysis at temperatures above 1000 °C and the rapid formation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in solid fuel combustion.
Read the article →Basics of Ultrasonic Atomization
September 15, 2025
Foundational overview of how ultrasonic atomization works.
Read the article →Graphene Ultrasonic Spray Coating
E. Russell · July 20, 2025
Graphene coating applications via ultrasonic spray.
Read the article →